full transcript

From the Ted Talk by Marlene Zuk: What we learn from insects' sex lives

Unscramble the Blue Letters

But that's just not the case. So for example, take katydids, which are relatives of crickets and grasshoppers. The males are very pckiy about who they mate with, because they not only tsarefnr sperm during mating, they also give the female something called a nautpil gift. You can see two ktdiydas mating in these photos. In both panels, the male's the one on the right, and that sword-like appendage is the female's egg-laying oargn. The white blob is the srpem, the green blob is the nuptial gift, and the male manufactures this from his own body and it's extremely costly to produce. It can weigh up to a third of his body mass. I will now pause for a moment and let you think about what it would be like if human men, every time they had sex, had to produce something that weighed 50, 60, 70 pounds. (leugathr) Okay, they would not be able to do that very often. (Laughter) And indeed, neither can the katydids. And so what that means is the katydid males are very choosy about who they offer these nuptial gifts to. Now, the gift is very notiuiruts, and the female eats it during and after mating. So, the bigger it is, the better off the male is, because that means more time for his sperm to darin into her body and fertilize her eggs. But it also means that the males are very passive about mating, whereas the females are extremely aggressive and competitive, in an attempt to get as many of these nutritious nuptial gifts as they can. So, it's not exactly a stereotypical set of rules. Even more glrenelay though, males are actually not all that important in the lives of a lot of insects. In the social insects — the bees and wasps and ants — the individuals that you see every day — the ants going back and forth to your sugar bowl, the hoeny bees that are flitting from flower to flower — all of those are always female. People have had a hard time getting their head around that idea for miillnnea. The acninet Greeks knew that there was a class of bees, the drones, that are larger than the workers, although they disapproved of the drones' laziness because they could see that the drones just hang around the hive until the mtniag flight — they're the males. They hang around until the mating flight, but they don't participate in ghtiernag nectar or pollen. The Greeks couldn't figure out the drones' sex, and part of the ciuofonsn was that they were aarwe of the sningitg ability of bees but they found it difficult to believe that any animals that bore such a weapon could possibly be a fmaele. Aristotle tried to get involved as well. He suggested, "OK, if the stinging individuals are going to be the males ..." Then he got confused, because that would have meant the males were also taking care of the young in a colony, and he seemed to think that would be completely impossible. He then concluded that maybe bees had the organs of both sexes in the same individual, which is not that far-fetched, some animals do that, but he never really did get it figured out. And you know, even taody, my stuetdns, for instance, call every animal they see, including inescts, a male. And when I tell them that the ferocious army-ant soldiers with their giant jaws, used to defend the colony, are all always female, they seem to not quite believe me. (Laughter) And certainly all of the movies — Antz, Bee Movie — portray the main character in the social insects as being male. Well, what difference does this make? These are movies. They're fiction. They have talking animals in them. What dfrecienfe does it make if they talk like Jerry Seinfeld? I think it does matter, and it's a pbolerm that actually is part of a much deeepr one that has implications for medicine and haleth and a lot of other acetsps of our lives. You all know that scientists use what we call model systems, which are creatures — white rats or fruit felis — that are kind of stand-ins for all other animals, including people. And the idea is that what's true for a posren will also be true for the white rat. And by and large, that turns out to be the case. But you can take the idea of a meodl stysem too far. And what I think we've done, is use males, in any species, as though they are the model system. The norm. The way things are supposed to be. And females as a kind of variant — something scieapl that you only study after you get the basics down. And so, back to the insects. I think what that maens is that people just couldn't see what was in front of them. Because they assumed that the world's stage was largely occupied by male players and females would only have minor, walk-on roles. But when we do that, we really miss out on a lot of what nartue is like. And we can also miss out on the way natural, living things, indicnulg people, can vary. And I think that's why we've used males as moleds in a lot of maedcil rarceseh, something that we know now to be a problem if we want the results to apply to both men and women. Well, the last thing I really love about insects is something that a lot of people find unnerving about them. They have little, tiny bnaris with very little cgtinvoie atibliy, the way we normally think of it. They have complicated behavior, but they lack complicated brains. And so, we can't just think of them as though they're little people because they don't do things the way that we do. I really love that it's difficult to anthropomorphize insects, to look at them and just think of them like they're little people in exoskeletons, with six legs. (Laughter) Instead, you really have to accept them on their own temrs, because insects make us question what's normal and what's natural. Now, you know, people write fiction and talk about parallel universes. They speculate about the saeurrnupatl, maybe the spitirs of the departed walking among us. The allure of another world is something that people say is part of why they want to dabble in the paranormal. But as far as I'm concerned, who needs to be able to see dead people, when you can see live insects? Thank you. (Applause)

Open Cloze

But that's just not the case. So for example, take katydids, which are relatives of crickets and grasshoppers. The males are very _____ about who they mate with, because they not only ________ sperm during mating, they also give the female something called a _______ gift. You can see two ________ mating in these photos. In both panels, the male's the one on the right, and that sword-like appendage is the female's egg-laying _____. The white blob is the _____, the green blob is the nuptial gift, and the male manufactures this from his own body and it's extremely costly to produce. It can weigh up to a third of his body mass. I will now pause for a moment and let you think about what it would be like if human men, every time they had sex, had to produce something that weighed 50, 60, 70 pounds. (________) Okay, they would not be able to do that very often. (Laughter) And indeed, neither can the katydids. And so what that means is the katydid males are very choosy about who they offer these nuptial gifts to. Now, the gift is very __________, and the female eats it during and after mating. So, the bigger it is, the better off the male is, because that means more time for his sperm to _____ into her body and fertilize her eggs. But it also means that the males are very passive about mating, whereas the females are extremely aggressive and competitive, in an attempt to get as many of these nutritious nuptial gifts as they can. So, it's not exactly a stereotypical set of rules. Even more _________ though, males are actually not all that important in the lives of a lot of insects. In the social insects — the bees and wasps and ants — the individuals that you see every day — the ants going back and forth to your sugar bowl, the _____ bees that are flitting from flower to flower — all of those are always female. People have had a hard time getting their head around that idea for _________. The _______ Greeks knew that there was a class of bees, the drones, that are larger than the workers, although they disapproved of the drones' laziness because they could see that the drones just hang around the hive until the ______ flight — they're the males. They hang around until the mating flight, but they don't participate in _________ nectar or pollen. The Greeks couldn't figure out the drones' sex, and part of the _________ was that they were _____ of the ________ ability of bees but they found it difficult to believe that any animals that bore such a weapon could possibly be a ______. Aristotle tried to get involved as well. He suggested, "OK, if the stinging individuals are going to be the males ..." Then he got confused, because that would have meant the males were also taking care of the young in a colony, and he seemed to think that would be completely impossible. He then concluded that maybe bees had the organs of both sexes in the same individual, which is not that far-fetched, some animals do that, but he never really did get it figured out. And you know, even _____, my ________, for instance, call every animal they see, including _______, a male. And when I tell them that the ferocious army-ant soldiers with their giant jaws, used to defend the colony, are all always female, they seem to not quite believe me. (Laughter) And certainly all of the movies — Antz, Bee Movie — portray the main character in the social insects as being male. Well, what difference does this make? These are movies. They're fiction. They have talking animals in them. What __________ does it make if they talk like Jerry Seinfeld? I think it does matter, and it's a _______ that actually is part of a much ______ one that has implications for medicine and ______ and a lot of other _______ of our lives. You all know that scientists use what we call model systems, which are creatures — white rats or fruit _____ — that are kind of stand-ins for all other animals, including people. And the idea is that what's true for a ______ will also be true for the white rat. And by and large, that turns out to be the case. But you can take the idea of a _____ ______ too far. And what I think we've done, is use males, in any species, as though they are the model system. The norm. The way things are supposed to be. And females as a kind of variant — something _______ that you only study after you get the basics down. And so, back to the insects. I think what that _____ is that people just couldn't see what was in front of them. Because they assumed that the world's stage was largely occupied by male players and females would only have minor, walk-on roles. But when we do that, we really miss out on a lot of what ______ is like. And we can also miss out on the way natural, living things, _________ people, can vary. And I think that's why we've used males as ______ in a lot of _______ ________, something that we know now to be a problem if we want the results to apply to both men and women. Well, the last thing I really love about insects is something that a lot of people find unnerving about them. They have little, tiny ______ with very little _________ _______, the way we normally think of it. They have complicated behavior, but they lack complicated brains. And so, we can't just think of them as though they're little people because they don't do things the way that we do. I really love that it's difficult to anthropomorphize insects, to look at them and just think of them like they're little people in exoskeletons, with six legs. (Laughter) Instead, you really have to accept them on their own _____, because insects make us question what's normal and what's natural. Now, you know, people write fiction and talk about parallel universes. They speculate about the ____________, maybe the _______ of the departed walking among us. The allure of another world is something that people say is part of why they want to dabble in the paranormal. But as far as I'm concerned, who needs to be able to see dead people, when you can see live insects? Thank you. (Applause)

Solution

  1. students
  2. research
  3. difference
  4. honey
  5. ability
  6. nature
  7. person
  8. generally
  9. cognitive
  10. laughter
  11. system
  12. models
  13. nuptial
  14. insects
  15. confusion
  16. katydids
  17. transfer
  18. spirits
  19. gathering
  20. flies
  21. aware
  22. terms
  23. organ
  24. health
  25. female
  26. medical
  27. drain
  28. problem
  29. supernatural
  30. stinging
  31. means
  32. mating
  33. aspects
  34. today
  35. model
  36. deeper
  37. ancient
  38. sperm
  39. brains
  40. nutritious
  41. special
  42. including
  43. millennia
  44. picky

Original Text

But that's just not the case. So for example, take katydids, which are relatives of crickets and grasshoppers. The males are very picky about who they mate with, because they not only transfer sperm during mating, they also give the female something called a nuptial gift. You can see two katydids mating in these photos. In both panels, the male's the one on the right, and that sword-like appendage is the female's egg-laying organ. The white blob is the sperm, the green blob is the nuptial gift, and the male manufactures this from his own body and it's extremely costly to produce. It can weigh up to a third of his body mass. I will now pause for a moment and let you think about what it would be like if human men, every time they had sex, had to produce something that weighed 50, 60, 70 pounds. (Laughter) Okay, they would not be able to do that very often. (Laughter) And indeed, neither can the katydids. And so what that means is the katydid males are very choosy about who they offer these nuptial gifts to. Now, the gift is very nutritious, and the female eats it during and after mating. So, the bigger it is, the better off the male is, because that means more time for his sperm to drain into her body and fertilize her eggs. But it also means that the males are very passive about mating, whereas the females are extremely aggressive and competitive, in an attempt to get as many of these nutritious nuptial gifts as they can. So, it's not exactly a stereotypical set of rules. Even more generally though, males are actually not all that important in the lives of a lot of insects. In the social insects — the bees and wasps and ants — the individuals that you see every day — the ants going back and forth to your sugar bowl, the honey bees that are flitting from flower to flower — all of those are always female. People have had a hard time getting their head around that idea for millennia. The ancient Greeks knew that there was a class of bees, the drones, that are larger than the workers, although they disapproved of the drones' laziness because they could see that the drones just hang around the hive until the mating flight — they're the males. They hang around until the mating flight, but they don't participate in gathering nectar or pollen. The Greeks couldn't figure out the drones' sex, and part of the confusion was that they were aware of the stinging ability of bees but they found it difficult to believe that any animals that bore such a weapon could possibly be a female. Aristotle tried to get involved as well. He suggested, "OK, if the stinging individuals are going to be the males ..." Then he got confused, because that would have meant the males were also taking care of the young in a colony, and he seemed to think that would be completely impossible. He then concluded that maybe bees had the organs of both sexes in the same individual, which is not that far-fetched, some animals do that, but he never really did get it figured out. And you know, even today, my students, for instance, call every animal they see, including insects, a male. And when I tell them that the ferocious army-ant soldiers with their giant jaws, used to defend the colony, are all always female, they seem to not quite believe me. (Laughter) And certainly all of the movies — Antz, Bee Movie — portray the main character in the social insects as being male. Well, what difference does this make? These are movies. They're fiction. They have talking animals in them. What difference does it make if they talk like Jerry Seinfeld? I think it does matter, and it's a problem that actually is part of a much deeper one that has implications for medicine and health and a lot of other aspects of our lives. You all know that scientists use what we call model systems, which are creatures — white rats or fruit flies — that are kind of stand-ins for all other animals, including people. And the idea is that what's true for a person will also be true for the white rat. And by and large, that turns out to be the case. But you can take the idea of a model system too far. And what I think we've done, is use males, in any species, as though they are the model system. The norm. The way things are supposed to be. And females as a kind of variant — something special that you only study after you get the basics down. And so, back to the insects. I think what that means is that people just couldn't see what was in front of them. Because they assumed that the world's stage was largely occupied by male players and females would only have minor, walk-on roles. But when we do that, we really miss out on a lot of what nature is like. And we can also miss out on the way natural, living things, including people, can vary. And I think that's why we've used males as models in a lot of medical research, something that we know now to be a problem if we want the results to apply to both men and women. Well, the last thing I really love about insects is something that a lot of people find unnerving about them. They have little, tiny brains with very little cognitive ability, the way we normally think of it. They have complicated behavior, but they lack complicated brains. And so, we can't just think of them as though they're little people because they don't do things the way that we do. I really love that it's difficult to anthropomorphize insects, to look at them and just think of them like they're little people in exoskeletons, with six legs. (Laughter) Instead, you really have to accept them on their own terms, because insects make us question what's normal and what's natural. Now, you know, people write fiction and talk about parallel universes. They speculate about the supernatural, maybe the spirits of the departed walking among us. The allure of another world is something that people say is part of why they want to dabble in the paranormal. But as far as I'm concerned, who needs to be able to see dead people, when you can see live insects? Thank you. (Applause)

Frequently Occurring Word Combinations

ngrams of length 2

collocation frequency
fruit flies 2
nuptial gifts 2
social insects 2
model system 2

Important Words

  1. ability
  2. accept
  3. aggressive
  4. allure
  5. ancient
  6. animal
  7. animals
  8. anthropomorphize
  9. ants
  10. antz
  11. appendage
  12. applause
  13. apply
  14. aristotle
  15. aspects
  16. assumed
  17. attempt
  18. aware
  19. basics
  20. bee
  21. bees
  22. behavior
  23. bigger
  24. blob
  25. body
  26. bore
  27. bowl
  28. brains
  29. call
  30. called
  31. care
  32. case
  33. character
  34. choosy
  35. class
  36. cognitive
  37. colony
  38. competitive
  39. completely
  40. complicated
  41. concerned
  42. concluded
  43. confused
  44. confusion
  45. costly
  46. creatures
  47. crickets
  48. dabble
  49. day
  50. dead
  51. deeper
  52. defend
  53. departed
  54. difference
  55. difficult
  56. disapproved
  57. drain
  58. drones
  59. eats
  60. eggs
  61. exoskeletons
  62. extremely
  63. female
  64. females
  65. ferocious
  66. fertilize
  67. fiction
  68. figure
  69. figured
  70. find
  71. flies
  72. flight
  73. flitting
  74. flower
  75. front
  76. fruit
  77. gathering
  78. generally
  79. giant
  80. gift
  81. gifts
  82. give
  83. grasshoppers
  84. greeks
  85. green
  86. hang
  87. hard
  88. head
  89. health
  90. hive
  91. honey
  92. human
  93. idea
  94. implications
  95. important
  96. impossible
  97. including
  98. individual
  99. individuals
  100. insects
  101. instance
  102. involved
  103. jaws
  104. jerry
  105. katydid
  106. katydids
  107. kind
  108. knew
  109. lack
  110. large
  111. largely
  112. larger
  113. laughter
  114. laziness
  115. legs
  116. live
  117. lives
  118. living
  119. lot
  120. love
  121. main
  122. male
  123. males
  124. manufactures
  125. mass
  126. mate
  127. mating
  128. matter
  129. means
  130. meant
  131. medical
  132. medicine
  133. men
  134. millennia
  135. minor
  136. model
  137. models
  138. moment
  139. movie
  140. movies
  141. natural
  142. nature
  143. nectar
  144. norm
  145. normal
  146. nuptial
  147. nutritious
  148. occupied
  149. offer
  150. organ
  151. organs
  152. panels
  153. parallel
  154. paranormal
  155. part
  156. participate
  157. passive
  158. pause
  159. people
  160. person
  161. photos
  162. picky
  163. players
  164. pollen
  165. portray
  166. possibly
  167. pounds
  168. problem
  169. produce
  170. question
  171. rat
  172. rats
  173. relatives
  174. research
  175. results
  176. roles
  177. rules
  178. scientists
  179. seinfeld
  180. set
  181. sex
  182. sexes
  183. social
  184. soldiers
  185. special
  186. species
  187. speculate
  188. sperm
  189. spirits
  190. stage
  191. stereotypical
  192. stinging
  193. students
  194. study
  195. sugar
  196. suggested
  197. supernatural
  198. supposed
  199. system
  200. systems
  201. talk
  202. talking
  203. terms
  204. time
  205. tiny
  206. today
  207. transfer
  208. true
  209. turns
  210. universes
  211. unnerving
  212. variant
  213. vary
  214. walking
  215. wasps
  216. weapon
  217. weigh
  218. weighed
  219. white
  220. women
  221. workers
  222. world
  223. write
  224. young